Drill Case
Map and Score
Map real procedures to ATT&CK techniques, then pick the CVSS v3.1 metrics for real vulnerabilities.
The case
Findings get mapped and scored before they go in a report. ATT&CK gives the shared vocabulary for what happened, and CVSS gives the number everyone will argue about.
Map real, documented procedures to techniques first. Then read real vulnerabilities and pick the metrics that score them.
What you will be able to do
- Recognize a technique from a description of what an adversary actually did (ATT&CK Coverage Map)
- Place a technique under the right tactic: the "why they did it", not the "what"
- Order a set of techniques into the sequence an intrusion realistically follows
- Use ATT&CK IDs as the shared vocabulary a report and a detection rule both refer to (Cyber Kill Chain)
- Derive a CVSS v3.1 Base vector from a vulnerability description, rather than inheriting one from an advisory (CVSS v3.1 Calculator)
- Tell Attack Vector apart from delivery. A mailed document that is opened locally is still a Local attack
- Use Attack Complexity for conditions outside the attacker's control, not for "this looks difficult"
- Decide Scope by asking whether the exploited component and the impacted one share a security authority
- Score partial impact as Low instead of rounding everything up to High
Read first: ATT&CK Coverage Map, CVSS v3.1 Calculator.
Notes for teaching it
- Every prompt is a real MITRE procedure example, so answers can always be checked against the technique page rather than against an instructor's opinion.
- The ordering question has one graded answer but real intrusions vary. It is worth saying out loud that the drill grades the canonical tactic order, and that a defensible alternative ordering is a good discussion, not a wrong answer.
- Free-text, not multiple choice, so partial recall shows up honestly. Expect a lower score than a class is used to and frame it before they start.
- The one drill here about judgment rather than recall, so it works best discussed out loud: ask learners to defend a metric before revealing the answer.
- Every answer is FIRST.org's own published example, not a house opinion. Worth stating: where a class disagrees with the answer, the productive question is which fact in the scenario the standard is keying on.
- Scope is where most of the disagreement lands, and that is the point. The VMware and Chrome cases are a deliberate pair: one crosses an authority boundary and one does not, with otherwise similar impact.
- Heartbleed is the case worth ending on. A 7.5 for the most famous vulnerability of its decade lands the idea that the score measures impact on the three properties, not fame or blast radius.
- Base metrics only. If someone asks why a known-exploited flaw does not score higher, that is Temporal and Environmental: deliberately out of scope here and in the calculator.
Terms behind it
- MITRE ATT&CK: A public knowledge base of real adversary tactics and techniques.
- Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures: How an adversary operates: their goals, methods, and step-by-step execution.
- Common Vulnerability Scoring System: An open framework that scores vulnerability severity from 0 to 10.
- TTP Mapping: Translating observed malware behavior into named adversary techniques.
Worksheet
Every question on one page, to print or to read without JavaScript. The answer key has the answers and why.
ATT&CK, 14 questions
-
Which MITRE ATT&CK technique ID does this real procedure example describe? "DarkGate will retrieved encrypted commands from its command and control server for follow-on actions such as cryptocurrency mining." (Answer with the technique ID, e.g. "T1059" or "T1059.001".)
-
Masquerading (T1036) maps to which MITRE ATT&CK tactic? (type the tactic name, e.g. "Credential Access")
-
Which MITRE ATT&CK technique ID does this real procedure example describe? "Clambling has the ability to use Telnet for communication." (Answer with the technique ID, e.g. "T1059" or "T1059.001".)
-
Modify Registry (T1112) maps to which MITRE ATT&CK tactic? (type the tactic name, e.g. "Credential Access")
-
Which MITRE ATT&CK technique ID does this real procedure example describe? "APT28 has used a variety of public exploits, including CVE 2020-0688 and CVE 2020-17144, to gain execution on vulnerable Microsoft Exchange; they have also conducted SQL injection attacks against external websites." (Answer with the technique ID, e.g. "T1059" or "T1059.001".)
-
File and Directory Permissions Modification (T1222) maps to which MITRE ATT&CK tactic? (type the tactic name, e.g. "Credential Access")
-
Which MITRE ATT&CK technique ID does this real procedure example describe? "APT42 has used custom malware to steal login and cookie data from common browsers." (Answer with the technique ID, e.g. "T1059" or "T1059.001".)
-
Phishing (T1566) maps to which MITRE ATT&CK tactic? (type the tactic name, e.g. "Credential Access")
-
Which MITRE ATT&CK technique ID does this real procedure example describe? "In the Triton Safety Instrumented System Attack, TEMP.Veles engaged in network reconnaissance against targets of interest." (Answer with the technique ID, e.g. "T1059" or "T1059.001".)
-
Acquire Access (T1650) maps to which MITRE ATT&CK tactic? (type the tactic name, e.g. "Credential Access")
-
These five real MITRE ATT&CK techniques all show up in one intrusion. Click them into the order their tactics actually occur in the Enterprise kill chain (earliest first).
-
Order these four real MITRE ATT&CK techniques, from pre-attack recon through an established C2 channel, by where their tactics fall in the Enterprise kill chain (earliest first).
-
Order these five real MITRE ATT&CK techniques, from privilege escalation through to a ransomware-style impact, by where their tactics fall in the Enterprise kill chain (earliest first).
-
Order these four real MITRE ATT&CK techniques, spanning stealth through exfiltration, by where their tactics fall in the Enterprise kill chain (earliest first).
CVSS, 10 questions
-
OpenSSL Heartbleed (CVE-2014-0160). A missing bounds check in a TLS heartbeat handler lets any client on the network request more bytes back than it sent, and the server replies with adjacent process memory: potentially private keys or session data. No authentication is needed, no user has to do anything, and the flaw neither modifies data nor stops the service. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
GNU Bash "Shellshock" (CVE-2014-6271). Bash executes trailing commands smuggled inside an environment variable. Where a network service such as CGI passes attacker-controlled input into the environment, a remote unauthenticated request runs arbitrary commands as the service account, with no user interaction. The affected component and the impacted component are the same. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
VMware guest-to-host escape (CVE-2012-1516). A flaw in the hypervisor lets code inside a guest VM, running with ordinary privileges in that guest, execute code on the host. The attacker is authenticated to the guest but not to the host, and reaches the host over the virtual device interface without any user involvement. The host is fully compromised. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
Apache Tomcat XML parser replacement (CVE-2009-0783). A web application deployed on a shared Tomcat instance can replace the XML parser used by other applications on the same server. Doing so requires the attacker to already be able to deploy an application (an administrative capability) and no user interaction. Some data belonging to the other applications can be read and altered, and they can be disrupted, but none completely. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
SSLv3 POODLE (CVE-2014-3566). An attacker positioned on the network can force a downgrade to SSL 3.0 and then recover small amounts of plaintext, a session cookie say, from a victim's encrypted traffic. It needs the victim to be actively browsing to a site the attacker can influence, and the attack must be repeated many times against a specific block of ciphertext to succeed. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
DNS cache poisoning (Kaminsky) (CVE-2008-1447). Weak transaction-ID randomization lets an off-path attacker race a legitimate reply and insert a forged record into a recursive resolver's cache. Winning the race depends on timing the attacker cannot fully control. No credentials and no user interaction are needed. The resolver itself keeps working and leaks nothing, but every client relying on it is now directed wherever the attacker chose. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
Sophos Disk Encryption login bypass (CVE-2014-2005). Someone with the machine physically in front of them can bypass the pre-boot login screen and reach the decrypted system, with full control over it afterwards. No credentials are required and nobody else has to do anything. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
Apple iWork file parsing (CVE-2015-1098). Opening a maliciously crafted document triggers memory corruption and arbitrary code execution in the context of the user who opened it. The file has to be delivered to that user and they have to open it. The attacker needs no account on the machine, and the impact is confined to that user's security context. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
Juniper proxy ARP denial of service (CVE-2013-6014). A device on the same network segment can send traffic that makes the router stop forwarding, taking down connectivity for everything behind it. No credentials, no user interaction. The router also exposes memory contents in the process. The systems knocked offline are not the router itself. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
-
Chrome PDFium JPEG 2000 parsing (CVE-2016-1645). A crafted image inside a PDF triggers an out-of-bounds write in the browser's PDF renderer, running attacker code with the browser's privileges once the victim visits a page hosting the file. No account is needed. The code lands inside the renderer sandbox, which is the same security authority as the vulnerable component. Give the CVSS v3.1 Base metric for each field below, as either the letter or the value's name.
Attack Vector (AV): N = Network, A = Adjacent, L = Local, P = Physical Attack Complexity (AC): L = Low, H = High Privileges Required (PR): N = None, L = Low, H = High User Interaction (UI): N = None, R = Required Scope (S): U = Unchanged, C = Changed Confidentiality (C): H = High, L = Low, N = None Integrity (I): H = High, L = Low, N = None Availability (A): H = High, L = Low, N = None
Next: Decode Range. All drills