CyberKit

Event IDs

Security event 4649

A replay attack was detected

Channel: Security. Category: Logon/Logoff (Audit Other Logon/Logoff Events).

What it records

Generated on a domain controller when the KDC returns KRB_AP_ERR_REPEAT. It received a Kerberos authenticator (server name, client name, timestamp, microseconds) that duplicates one it has already cached from a recent request.

Why it matters

A duplicated authenticator can indicate an actual attempt to replay a captured Kerberos ticket/authenticator, though Microsoft notes it is also produced by mundane causes.

What triggers it

Per Microsoft's own guidance, one potential cause is a misconfigured network device between client and server retransmitting or duplicating the same packet, rather than malicious activity; though it can indicate a genuine replay attempt.

Fields that carry the answer

Key fields
FieldWhat it tells you
Account Name (Credentials Which Were Replayed)The account whose Kerberos authenticator was seen duplicated: the identity to check against expected activity before concluding this is either a genuine replay attempt or a benign network retransmission.
Workstation NameSource workstation named in the repeated authenticator, when captured, useful for tracing where the duplicate request originated.

In practice

Logged when Windows detects what looks like a replayed Kerberos authenticator, e.g. from a client at 203.0.113.5 sitting behind a NAT gateway or proxy. Microsoft's own guidance notes this event more often results from network conditions duplicating a packet in transit than a genuine attack, so analysts treat a lone 4649 as low-fidelity and look for corroborating evidence before escalating.

Sample record

A replay attack was detected.

Subject:
	Security ID:		S-1-5-18
	Account Name:		DC01$
	Account Domain:		CORP
	Logon ID:		0x3E7

Credentials Which Were Replayed:
	Account Name:		jdoe
	Account Domain:		CORP.LOCAL

Process Information:
	Process ID:		0x260
	Process Name:		C:\Windows\System32\lsass.exe

Network Information:
	Workstation Name:	WKSTN-07

Detailed Authentication Information:
	Request Type:		KerbVerifyPacRequestMessage
	Logon Process:		Kerberos
	Authentication Package:	Kerberos
	Transited Services:	-

This event indicates that a Kerberos replay attack was detected - a request was received twice with identical information. This condition could be caused by network misconfiguration.

Sources

Paste a record into Event XML or open a log in EVTX Reader.