CyberKit

Analysis of Competing Hypotheses

Also called ACH.

A method that tests every explanation against the evidence to reduce analyst bias.

What it is

A structured analytic technique, developed by former CIA analyst Richards Heuer, that lays out all plausible hypotheses and evaluates each piece of evidence against every one of them in a matrix. Crucially, it works by seeking to disprove hypotheses rather than confirm a favorite.

Why it matters

ACH counters confirmation bias by forcing analysts to consider alternatives they might otherwise dismiss, which is valuable in attribution and intrusion analysis where the obvious answer may be wrong or deliberately planted.

In practice

Running ACH on an attribution question and discarding the leading suspect because key evidence is inconsistent with it.

What to look for

  • Every plausible explanation listed up front.
  • Evidence that rules hypotheses out, not just in.
  • Key evidence that could be deceptive.

Common mistake

Looking only for evidence that supports your favorite. ACH works by trying to disprove each one.

Practice it nearby

CyberKit has no tool for this term itself. These are the closest places to practice it.

Read next

Sources