Constrained Delegation Abuse
Abusing S4U delegation to impersonate users to allowed services.
What it is
Abuse of Kerberos constrained delegation, where a service is permitted to obtain tickets to specific back-end services on behalf of a user via the S4U extensions. If an attacker controls a delegating account, they can request tickets impersonating arbitrary users to those services.
Why it matters
It allows impersonation of high-value users, including domain admins, to the configured target services without their credentials, and protocol-transition variants do not even require the user to authenticate first. The allowed-to-delegate-to list defines the blast radius.
In practice
After compromising a web service account configured for constrained delegation, an attacker forges a ticket impersonating an administrator to a database it is allowed to delegate to.
What to look for
- S4U2Self and S4U2Proxy requests from service accounts.
- Service tickets for privileged users that those users never asked for.
- Delegation settings pointing at sensitive services like LDAP or CIFS on DCs.
Common mistake
Thinking constrained means safe. If the delegating account is compromised, it can impersonate anyone to the allowed services.
Practice it nearby
CyberKit has no tool for this term itself. These are the closest places to practice it.
- Cloud Identity Case
A cloud account acting out of character: read its CloudTrail records and sign-ins, name the attack, and pick the containment.
- Event Log Reader
Read a binary .evtx file or pasted event XML, with logon types, NTSTATUS codes and the Keywords mask decoded.
In the field
Well-known tools where this shows up on the job. They are listed to show the landscape, not as a recommendation.
-
Microsoft Defender for Identity Commercial
Watches domain controller traffic and events for attacks such as Kerberoasting and DCSync.
-
BloodHound Open source
Maps attack paths through Active Directory, the same view an attacker builds.
-
Splunk Enterprise Security Commercial
Where many teams search domain controller logs, such as Kerberos ticket events, for these attacks.
Read next
- Unconstrained Delegation Abuse: Harvesting cached TGTs from a host trusted for unconstrained delegation.
- Resource-Based Constrained Delegation Abuse: Writing a delegation attribute on a target to impersonate users to it.
- Shadow Credentials: Adding attacker key material to an account for Kerberos auth.